2002 Pontiac Sunfire Cylinder 1 Misfire: From Specific to Random, Diagnosis & Fixes
Hi everyone, I'm looking for help diagnosing a persistent misfire issue on my 2002 Pontiac Sunfire. The engine appears to have been replaced by a previous owner with a Cavalier-style engine (same displacement), which may affect the diagnosis. The problem occurs primarily when the car is cold — I can hear a distinct 'puff-puff-puff' sound, evenly spaced, which seems to originate from cylinder 1. The issue diminishes at normal operating temperature but returns under cold conditions. I took it to a local garage last week. They diagnosed a misfire on cylinder 1 and replaced the spark plugs (AC Delco, installed by me). Afterward, the OBD2 code changed to 'random multiple misfires'. They then installed a used coil pack for cylinders 1 and 4, but the random misfire persists. The garage now recommends replacing both the Ignition Control Module (ICM) and the coil packs. I'm hesitant to proceed with further expensive repairs due to my fixed income and recent forced medical retirement — I have very limited emergency funds left. I recently watched a YouTube video suggesting that 'random multiple misfires' might actually indicate one cylinder that is intermittently misfiring, rather than true random failures. This makes me wonder: could the issue still be isolated to cylinder 1, now improved slightly by new plugs? Any suggestions or diagnostic steps would be greatly appreciated. As a follow-up step, I recently ordered an OBD2 code reader on eBay so I can monitor codes independently in the future and avoid relying solely on garage diagnostics.
If the misfire transitioned from specific to random, verify that AC DELCO spark plugs were used — BOSCH or discount brand plugs can cause inconsistent performance. Additionally, perform a fuel pressure test and a pressure leak-down check to rule out fuel delivery issues.