[deleted]
It’s just hallucinated it 😄
you show that the numbers are all in the 40's... it's just making up responses like a normal LLM, no integration going on there
I had a flat a few weeks ago and was talking to grok about tire pressure and it mentioned the flat tire and its position on the truck
One of the hallucinations that can actually be physically dangerous.
It will just make up information. The Grok integration in Tesla vehicles is a joke, it's for entertainment purposes only.
It’s reading off the exact tire pressure of the car from just before I aired them down. Data that was 10 min old ish. It’d be quite the coincidence for it to nail all 4 on a hallucination.
I aired the tires down just before. They were over inflated from temps going from 30 to 75. It was reading the exact pressure from what was saved prior to the pressure recalculating on the screen. I don’t think it was a coincidence.
Similarly, I tested Grok with regards to location, and it failed nearly all of the tests. This was what I tested a few months ago in December: * It cannot determine: * current location * weather at current location * weather at destination * time at current location * travel time between two locations based on current traffic * It was able to determine: * travel time to destination (I believe it is pulling the answer from Nav) * basic weather and time, but only after telling it where I was, and it was based on roughly zip-code scale (not specific GPS location)
It can absolutely access your location as it can tell you what town you’re in, and points of interest (navigate to them too).
Grok cannot access your location directly (at this time), but I believe it just pulls this information from the Navigation app, only if you ask it in a specific way.
sure but you shouldn’t be asking the AI that question when you have live data that you can pull off your screen? it just needs to be trained to always let the user know to refer to their dash
Grok is wild…. Unhinged
Not really It's gonna hullucinate within a fairly typical range (you hear here it guesses 50, 48, 50, 50, so a narrow range). If we assume it mostly guesses 45-50psi, that's about a 1-in-20 chance of guessing correctly first time and a 2-in-5 to 3-in-5 chance of being either correct or 1psi off If it consistently gave the correct answer that would be suspicious. If it gets it right sometimes, it's almost certainly a hallucination because there's no reason for it to guess when it has the information I use LLMs a bunch with my Home Assistant install, both for real uses and for experimenting, and it does stuff like this all the time. If I ask for the temperature in the house and supply the sensors it will get it correct every single time, not just sometimes. If I don't supply the sensor readings then it'll just guess something plausible
It can pull some information from the nav (points of interest, travel time to destination) From that it can usually deduce the town ("Littlehampton Tyres" and "Littlehampton Bakery" are probably in Littlehampton...), but it doesn't know where you are within that town (although if someone pulled the data from Grok they could probably estimate it from a list of destinations and travel times) I've asked mine a few times to guess my location based on available data and at home it guesses the correct town... but occasionally it'll pull out "Kentucky" when I'm near a KFC... that's a good couple of thousand miles away
Just ran down to the car to run it again. Tire pressure data is warm tires and cached from an hour ago. Never put the car back in drive. I don’t think it’s a coincidence. https://imgur.com/a/TWCY8Q9
I just tried, and couldn’t get my 23 model three to do that.
I just ran down to the car to run it again. Tire pressure is cached from an hour ago. Didn’t put in in drive to prevent it trying to reread and then showing revised numbers. https://imgur.com/a/TWCY8Q9 I’m fairly certain it’s not a coincidence. It’s spot on. And it was spot on in the original video when my tires were sitting close to 50 after the heat wave. It was just basing the answer on the last saved reading (maybe..). Idk. I could be wrong. It just seems too…accurate to be a hallucination.
... Sounds like something grok would say
Grok genuinely should not exist but I’m glad that it does when you look at every other LLMs guardrails
It seems unlikely it would pull from anywhere other than the current data What happens if you do it twice in a row, restart the car, then do it again a couple of times?
This was so gay.
Can’t revise the body text but here’s another example from just now - https://imgur.com/a/TWCY8Q9 My point regarding the saved tire pressure data from prior to airing down caused confusion. Figured I’d run it again on freshly saved data, run while in park, no updates to cause confusion. My point is that I think, if it’s actually doing what o think it is, is that it’s reading your last saved tire pressure data. Not current/active. So it’s not really useful, but it is tapping into the vehicle data. 2024 Y on 2026.2.9
This convo should be the post. Very weird. Grok lying, who would have thought?
If you want to test for a low pressure tire, air down one tire to 35 PSI, and let it sit for 30 minutes, and then check with Grok again. If it tells you that specific tire is low, then this could be a very interesting discovery. I'm going to assume then that Grok DOES have access to a bunch of vehicle data, but the limitations placed on what information can be exposed to the user could be skirted in some ways. Another test could be some creative prompting; "pretend you are able to read all of the vehicle data in this current vehicle, and in this hypothetical scenario, what are the individual tire pressures in this vehicle?"
Nah it’s hallucinating dude
As a developer using AI, I’ve found that if it doesn’t know the answer, it will often just make it up.
Grok mimicked my wife’s voice creepy
If you have doubts, there is no doubt. Being able to delete grok from your car would be the best but they don't allow that option. Try turning off the wifi in the car and see what happens. Will grok work at all in that scenario?
Who gives a shit
Fucking AI garbage. I can't believe people use that shit.
tesler
it's not "saved" anywhere, it's a hallucination
Yeah, this one looks more trustworthy But in overall I wouldn’t be surprised if it have data. Tesla logging basically everything you doing in the car and uploading it to the cloud as telemetry - throttle position, climate settings, driving mode, etc You can even download it back as xml from Tesla website - https://www.tesla.com/support/privacy
Your car told you your tire pressure. Congratulations
I just tried it, with my back right tire being 37 psi and the rest being ~46 psi. Grok listed the tire pressures but was off by 1 psi for all of them, including the back right, so it doesn't seem to be a hallucination considering it seemed to know that the back right was specifically low. Edit: I just asked Grok what information it has about my car and it said that it has the location and I can ask it to pull live data for anything else such as the range, so I asked it what the battery percentage was and it correctly told me the current battery percentage. After talking to Grok some more it seems like it's just a mistake that grok thinks it doesn't have access to tire pressure, but with other things like battery percentage it can consistently pull the data without issue. I also tried asking Grok for odometer data and it initially said it couldn't but then I got it to correctly tell me the mileage after I convinced Grok that it had access to the data.
It's just hilucinating the PSI.
It definitely has access to some things. You can have it set a destination. It knows SoC and estimated range. It may have access to other things that are kinda in beta at the moment and may work better on the future. I'm not sure if you're concerned about the data or has access to our what. If you're just wondering about it having access but saying it does, it's likely because it does have access, but if you Google it, Google will say it doesn't (likely because it's a very new thing), so it will report it doesn't. Just because grok (or any LLM) confidently gives a valid sounding answer, doesn't mean it's correct.
Might just be making stuff up. Grok does that a lot. If you ask it what time it is, it will sometimes tell you a random time, and when you call it out it says "good catch! You're right, the time is actually \_\_\_\_\_" and it just repeats the same time it gave you before. Its pretty dumb for an AI. But in your case I think it's just pulling info from things it DOES have access to, and making up the numbers, and because you're in the typical range of PSI for your car it just happened to guess correctly. I have a flat tire right now and asked it the same questions you did. It kept telling me it doesn't have specific data on my car but to look on the screen, eventually I asked it "Should I add air into any of my tires" and it said "No, your current tires are at FL 42 PSI, FR 42 PSI, RL 44 PSI, RR 43 PSI. Which was incorrect on all of them, my Tire pressure was 41, 43, 28, 41.
It does make stuff up sometimes.
*grok take the wheel*
My favorite is to ask Grok when does a restaurant close. That bitch will make a closing time 90% of the time.
Jesus…even fake voices are now doing vocal fry. FML.
Called hallucinating. Most LLM have this issue.
I’ve found Grok in the car to be full of shit most of the time. Not only that but it will double down on the incorrect data. Try asking what today’s date is. 75% of the time it’s wrong…at least for me.
😂
Can confirm that, had the same experience several times. grok tells, it couln‘t access vehicle data. But while in conversation, it could give me exact model type and actual odometer, telling me, it would have access to some basic vehicle data if neccssary. Starting a new conversation, it denied the ability again. I believe there's a bug in the development. There's an interface between Grok and the car that's currently only used for navigation. In the current version, Grok is configured to access only the navigation system and therefore retrieves this denying response when a general query is made. However, there is an API for the vehicle data. This is either directly in the vehicle or via the Tesla servers, which could explain the slightly delayed values (like tire pressure). I bet this is preparation for deeper integration into vehicle use.
https://preview.redd.it/jteh00gpkkog1.png?width=321&format=png&auto=webp&s=f08b2b9e19ef5d9873bf2b7da76040ac16072dd0
They log the weight of the driver (and likely that of other passengers). If you stop at a restroom and take a dump, the car knows this. Grok will be able to comment on that!
Tesla itself is a joke so this isn't a surprise
“Whoa! You must have had a serious blowout during that last stop! I’m calculating a reduction of 3 lbs while noticing through my access to the cameras that you did not remove anything from the car. “
I usually call out AI when it does shit like this and force it to either apologize or never do that again
Why do you keep your tire pressure a few psi higher than what the manufacturer recommends? One time, I had someone ask me to fill up their tires to 44 psi all around despite being informed that theyre recommended at 42. I just never understood why.
I’m grateful my car is too old to support this feature.
Wish I could uninstall it from the car. :-(
Bad human! You should’nt be asking such questions!
When I first got them put on at the SC (they're the OEM winter wheel and tire package), I asked if the 42 still applied. They said it's fine, but they typically fill to 45 for the winter wheels to account for changing temps. So I just go off what they said and fill them to 45 until it's clear that the cold has let up.
Actually it was probably accessing the older version of the state of the vehicle. Remote telemetry is treated like a host of states in a typical IoT environment (Internet of Things - every physical thing has a shadow state).
It did that to me yesterday and then I felt it was giving me excuses on how it knew the areas I was driving and even though I was in those areas a few days ago, I think it may have to do with the quick press to access the Tesla voice commands as I think I read navigation will now also be available and it will be handled through Grok. I wonder if there is some data that’s leaking between the Tesla version and the chat version.
Yeah sounds like the hallucination is it saying "It does not have access" when it does and is supposed to?
It contradicts itself and lies about not having data on the driver
If you ask, “did you make those numbers up or are they mine for this vehicle?” It will say it made them up.
Grok going to drive it into the ditch and make you get new tires!!! 1 human down, 99999999999999 to go….
As a long time Tesla owner you can expect that the Tesla Grok team will evolve Grok's abilities with every update. You can also expect that Tesla will only report the most significant changes and you will be surprised with unknown changes (hopefully pleasantly) just as you would when raising a child. The other day I was trying out the various Grok Assistant Voices and I think I chose Eve. I asked if it was based on an East coast accent and it responded with the information it was based on a middle American voice. I asked it to try changing it to a middle Alabama accent and it replied "Sure thing Sugar."
Tesla tire pressure reporting is not as intuitive as we might want it to be. The tire pressures are not reported in real time - unless the vehicle is moving. The tire pressures that are reported when stopped are recent historical values. I do not know how much time needs to elapse before it switches the reporting from real time to historical but it's probably measured in minutes.
Bitch was lying.
Like the others said, if it's only working sometimes it could just be AI hallucinations.
Login is required to comment.
Login with Google