← Back to topic list

Keep Tesla M3 or get Lucid

Ricketswicket | 2026-03-04 03:27 | 9 views

Have a Tesla model 3 on finance payment with another 3 years left but warranty has expired. With the discounts on offer a new lucid air is coming in roughly equal to the same monthly payments as my finance payments but on lease terms. Question - do I continue with Tesla now that warranty has expired and keep on for 3 years. Or move to lucid - new car. New warranty. But no car in 3 years and back to leasing or buying The M3 has been solid with no maintenance of any sort other than air filter changes and tire changes. But I have read out of warranty Tesla is an expensive thing Thoughts?

Comments (31)
mrplt 2026-03-04 03:29

What's the year and mileage of your Model 3? Test drive the Lucid Air and see if you like it at all. I found it to be underwhelming. You could also look into financing a different EV? Perhaps another Model 3?

norf937 2026-03-04 03:29

If you do go Lucid I would lease.. Their future is pretty uncertain at the moment. My father in law had a Lucid Air on lease a few years ago though, I thought the quality & fit and finish was better than Tesla but everything else especially the tech and UI was subpar.

farmerMac 2026-03-04 03:30

Depends on how much money you’ve got. Tesla are pretty reliable.

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 03:32

cheers, its a 2021 tesla - with 80k KM on it. Drove the Air - absolutely loved it - and the interior was another level. Level head in me says stick to M3 and ride it out for 3-4 years.…though….YOLO….lol…hence here to get some sense stuffed into me

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 03:34

Yup only option id consider

PatienceBig9727 2026-03-04 03:36

ask your wife. no wife? YOLO

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 03:39

Meg….is that you……;p

Ill_Aside_5662 2026-03-04 03:43

The lucid subreddit has steered me completely from them. They have some sick looking cars though.

short_bus_genius 2026-03-04 03:45

Honest question... have you seen this video? [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1WiQAOmESH0](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1WiQAOmESH0) Lucid owner goes in depth on issues with the software.

Jorge_14-64Kw 2026-03-04 03:45

Another thing to consider is how close are you to a Lucid & Tesla service center. If you have a Lucid service center somewhat close by I would go Lucid. I own both a Lucid and a 3. The Lucid is so much more car than the 3 especially once you pick up friends/family. The space is just incredible. Good luck with your decision. Cheers!

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 03:48

Yep - a lot of those are older firmware - I believe that youtuber has an updated video talking about things that have resolved. Either ways first gen tech doesn’t faze me. I had the 85d‘s with the MCU failing and going dark for mins during my commute lol.

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 03:51

amen, the rear is insane - I plan to never sit in it tho lol. And yes SC is roughly 30 mins drive - like Tesla. though I’ve heard the Lucid SC has quite the backlog, so definitely weighing on my mind.

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 03:53

interesting - seeing a split on other Tesla forums and threads. Much like any car….curious if I were to budget for potential failures that are likely on a M3 - how much would I budget for the next 4 years?

dextroz 2026-03-04 04:00

Stay away from Lucid!

UnfazedBrownie 2026-03-04 04:06

Ask yourself if the warranty truly matters? I can give you my experience. I have a 3 also that I bought 7.5 years ago that has about 125k miles on it. It’s been out of the vehicle warranty for 4 years and the batter warranty for about a year. You might still have the batter warranty but keep in mind it’s whatever hits first (mikes or years). The control arm (front right) had a recall and was replaced by Tesla. This was also within the warranty period. The only other item I’ve had to deal with was replacing the front right headlamp assembly. This happened a year ago. I’m out of warranty so the Tesla quote was $1600. Since this car has become pretty common everywhere, I figured there were enough mechanics and you tube videos. The part is expensive ($1300) but you can get it from suppliers online. I spent $200. It’s OEM but had a scratch on the inside. I replaced it and paired it myself. This has been the only issue I’ve had with the vehicle. I’m probably going to drive it into the ground.

OldFargoan 2026-03-04 04:08

If it were me I'd ride it out and own the Tesla, then trade it for a 3 year old Lucid as soon as it's paid off. Don't do what I do.

SubieSTI360 2026-03-04 04:10

I’m still trying to figure out how you financed the 3 over 8 years!

Spokane_Al 2026-03-04 04:17

No FSD is a deal killer for me - i ain’t moving backwards, no matter how fancy looking the car.

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 04:17

super low interest - long term spread - invested cash into VFV to keep steady growth.

Ricketswicket 2026-03-04 04:20

If I could up vote you 10x I would - looking for this type of feedback for sure. Thanks

SpliffDragon 2026-03-04 04:28

There’s only one right answer and you know it

RedBandsblu 2026-03-04 04:29

Go with an extended warranty, with decent care your M3 batter could last 4-5 times as many miles as you have now, a Lucid is not going to last 200k km

loudrats 2026-03-04 04:51

Best car ever driven if you can ignore the software issues. I drive the Sapphire.

loudrats 2026-03-04 04:52

What do you find underwhelming about the Lucid Air?

Weekly_Strawberry_70 2026-03-04 05:04

Do you not use FSD? I can’t switch because i like fsd so much

pachewychomp 2026-03-04 07:39

If you have a 2021 3/Y, the chances of your HV battery going bad is higher than other year 3/Ys.

SimilarComfortable69 2026-03-04 14:59

The most expensive thing you're doing is paying payments. Focus on that. Don't focus on the possibility that you might have to pay something for your model three down the road.

pretzelgreg317 2026-03-04 15:06

How old is your M3? what mileage? You should be aware that short of rare battery pack issues there is not much potential "failure" on the car. Control arms could be more robust (but are easily enough replaced and not an expensive repair) and other normal wear and tear on a well driven vehicle. If you are happy with the car and you are still making payments you should put your anti marketing sunglasses on and drive it till you can't/have it paid off and some money saved towards your next one.

Howry 2026-03-04 15:43

Check to see if you have a service center near by if needed if you are going to think about Lucid. I live in Oregon and there is one in Seattle. 5 hours away or Sacramento 8 hours away which kills it for me. Just to far away to make it viable if there is a problem.

Tbond222 2026-03-04 15:57

Lucid

Theminecraf72 2026-03-04 19:07

Only thing is Lucids future is not really certain. The saudis are just pumping more and more money into it

Add comment

Login is required to comment.

Login with Google