MYP stock rims to 19” or 20” forged?

Konstanteen | 2026-03-09 15:20 | 6 views

Looking at getting Martian MW05.2 in either 19” or 20”. I’ve bent one of the original rims and have sidewalk damage, so it’s time for new shoes. I obviously want the protection of 19”, but like the look of 20”. Since I’m going to forged rims, do we think 20” is enough sidewall or do I just go all the way to 19”? Anyone have pics of these rims on your Tesla?

Comments (6)

TheRayATL 2026-03-09 16:07

I’d go with the 19s. I value comfort over looks and the 19s will look just fine. I live in houston so the roads are dogshit, which is why i downsized from the god awful 21” uberturbines on my 2024 myp. Didn’t put the same rims that you mentioned though.

Konstanteen 2026-03-09 16:30

Thanks, I do really value the looks which is why I am torn (and why I’m considering spending my bonus on this price point of rim - no kids, treat yo self). I know the stock cast rims are shit and I’m tired of the vibration from having a slight dent. My brother got a M3P which felt smooth as butter when he got it - 2 weeks later I felt the same small vibration mine has and sure enough he had a bend too. Really looking forward to forged rims and a bit more sidewall to absorb potholes.

EitherCharacter9342 2026-03-09 18:43

19's

snakefighting 2026-03-09 21:24

20”… but I love my 21” on the MY Performance. Hard to downsize when I look at her..

Konstanteen 2026-03-09 21:51

I’m thinking going to stronger forged rims and downsizing to 20” should be enough. I hate to sacrifice the looks so much and go 19”. This may be a decision I regret, but I’ll look good regretting it.

snakefighting 2026-03-09 22:10

Yeah, I’m made the same way! Share what you pick out, interested.

Add comment