My model 3 has two different VIN’s associated with the car..?

how crazy... especially since you bought it directly from tesla; my guess is they didn't run throughout-enough due diligence on the vehicle before reselling it after receiving... first, i would double check all documentation of the sale and see if any of this was disclosed — if it was disclosed, that may hurt your case a bit... second, document everything — photograph both VINs (A-pillar and B-pillar), pull the carfax/autocheck reports for both VINs, + save original purchase agreement and any representations Tesla made about the vehicle's condition and history i think the core issue is your car likely had major structural components replaced using parts from a salvage/rebuilt title vehicle... i would consider the A-pillar is a structural, safety-critical component; body shops refusing to touch it is telling — they def don't want the liability of certifying work on a car with questionable structural integrity / provenance i'd contact tesla directly + escalate to their used vehicle sales team and put everything in writing (email, etc. with all docs collected) — explain the VIN mismatch and request they unwind the sale entirely or make it right... they sold you this vehicle, so they have significant exposure here if you need to escalate this because they won't budge / try claim that cars are sold "as-is"... you can first threaten to tesla (or just move forward with) filing a complaint with your state attorney general's consumer protection division; selling a vehicle with undisclosed structural damage from a rebuilt-title donor car is likely a violation of state consumer protection and auto dealer fraud statutes tesla is a licensed dealer and they have to follow disclosure obligations; if it ends up escalating, you may not only be entitled to a full unwind but potentially additional damages depending on your state's consumer protection laws mind keeping us updated on this? curious how everything turns out.. crazy situation

look up the vin in the screen and see which it matches. You might have someone elses parts

Thank you for such a thorough reply! I didn’t want to reach back out until I had a little information. I just got back from my local Tesla service centre and ran them through the situation, needless to say nobody had ever heard of this and weren’t very much help. They just kept saying the car is still a clean title and passed their inspection and a used vehicle is “as is” and that they can’t really help. I brought up the point that they obviously didn’t inspect the frame or structural safety of the vehicle very thoroughly if they have never realized it has mismatching VIN’s. Especially seeing as this car must’ve been inspected countless times at this point since it was an original lease vehicle that was serviced and then resold at this same location. Unfortunately that didn’t change the matter so I am now left with an option of forgetting about this whole situation or contacting a lawyer.

Surprised because this is a massive consumer protection liability for Tesla — my guess is the folks you spoke with don’t understand the legal risk and you need to speak with someone higher up who understands the gravity of this situation.. It is a massive liability. Full stop. I would start the process of submitting all of this information to consumer protection agency for your state and get the receipts from that. Bring it with you to your discussion with Tesla when you get higher up the chain.